Hey Kirill L. I don't even track open rates unless it's at the very beginning of a campaign to quickly measure my deliverability. Past that, it's a really bad indicator of deliverability imo. Reply rates have always been a more reliable indicator of deliverability from my experience. Yes, it's important to have a good offer that's relevant to your prospect, but if you get less than 1% response rates, there's most likely a deliverability problem to be fixed. Thoughts?
I am in no way trying to force my opinion on you and tell you that you are wrong. Everyone has their own approach and the most important thing is to show results. Right, open rate is not always honest, some percentage of the total opens are made by anti-spam robots. My approach is simple: open rate - shows delivery problems (you have to check the infrastructure) reply rate can be divided into two variants: positive - we did a good job and managed to move the lead through the funnel. negative - we are working on our offer and triggers (signaling a need). Of course, there are many more variables inside. But this is how I approach my funnel. Thank you for sharing your experience.
Yeah I'm aware, no stress! I just love debating this stuff, it's what I do for a living and I love it when people have different opinions. I agree with the reply rate assessment, but getting 0 replies has always been due to bad deliverability for all the campaigns I've ever run. Every time I got less than 1-2% reply rate, I'd fix my deliverability, and reply rate would shoot up. Same lead lists, same messaging. I used to check open rates for deliverability too, but it's honestly a very unreliable metric and it really varies from provider to provider. I now only use it for the very beginning of a campaign, and then rely solely on reply rates.
When you get a negative response, you say "we are working on our offer and triggers". Do I understand it well that if you get a lot of negatives, you work on improving your offer and triggers?
Very glad we're having a good discussion. I can talk about this subject for a long time - I have been in sales all my life. It's a pleasure to meet you. You understood me right about reworking after a negative letter. You know better than me that there are different types of negative responses - "we're not interested", "let's talk later", "unsubscribe me", "I'm not the one you need", etc. And there is a lot of room for work here - refining the ICP, changing the initial value proposition, choosing the right signal when to send an email, etc.