We use both 馃槀
Both have pros/cons. Depends on what you and your clients opt for. Both also are always coming out with great features for different use cases.
To give any insights on my take:
Instantly鈥檚 UI IMO is a bit cleaner and simplier.
Smartlead utility is a bit more robust (especially their API).
If you鈥檙e looking for simple, go Instantly.
If you鈥檙e looking to build backend APIs and need the utility and don鈥檛 care so much on on a simple UI, go Smartlead. Just my opinion.