IMO the simplest way to start with scoring in Clay is just rule-based weights, nothing fancy.
Pick 4–6 clear signals tied to your ICP. For example:
+3 exact title match
+2 company size in range
+2 right industry
+1 relevant tech
−3 wrong persona
Add a formula column that sums the points. Then bucket into tiers (e.g. 7+ = Tier A, 5–6 = Tier B).
To test if it works, run outbound separately to Tier A vs Tier B with the same messaging and compare reply and meeting rates. If Tier A doesn’t outperform, adjust the weights. Start simple, measure performance, then iterate.