Mitch, thank you for your response; however, it is not really helpful.
I don't need to look up against that column - it's AI-generated with some discrepancies in it. 'Final' exists exactly why you mentioned - I'm manually checking and cleaning them.
My reasoning that it is a bug is simple - the column was working perfectly at 11am my time and simply stopped working at 11.15. Same cell, same data. If I rerun the same cell (with no data changed inside the cell) - it generates zero results instead of 20 records.
Example:
Column 'Domain' has abb.com, Column 'Final' has abb.com (copied from Domain). The first column works and finds 20 records, the second column does not work and gives 'No records found' as a response.